Why avoid plastic-only plant covers?

Published: May 31, 2025
Updated: May 31, 2025

Plastic-only covers produce lethal condensation and then refreeze on leaves. I lit an entire row of lettuce when trapped moisture froze to ice crystals overnight! This material doesn't breathe and, as such, creates a microclimate that can be as much as 5°F cooler than uncovered plants in certain conditions. Always combine plastic with a layer of insulation, like burlap or frost cloth.

Plant Cover Material Comparison
MaterialPlastic sheetingCondensation Risk
High
R-Value0.3Best Use CaseTemporary top layer only
MaterialFrost clothCondensation Risk
Low
R-Value1.5Best Use CasePrimary cover material
MaterialBurlapCondensation Risk
Medium
R-Value0.8Best Use CaseWindbreak over plastic
R-value measures thermal resistance per inch of material

Layered Approach

  • Place plastic 6+ inches above breathable fabric
  • Use PVC hoops to maintain air gaps
  • Secure edges with ground staples every 18 inches
  • Remove completely when temps exceed 45°F

Danger Signs

  • Visible droplets on underside of plastic
  • Plant leaves touching cover surface
  • Daytime temps above 50°F under cover
  • Prolonged use beyond 36 hours

Moisture patterns in a region can directly influence the risks of applying plastic coverings. In our studies, coastal growers experience a 40% increase in condensation than desert growers. I need to remove plastic daily from my greenhouse in Florida, and often I see my counterparts in Arizona leave single or double covers on for 48 hours without removal. You can track relative humidity in a microclimate from wireless sensors for more accurate control.

Options are available for emergency purposes. Old shower curtains can be effective if mounted on tomato cages. For example, I reuse billboard vinyl scraps, because their small holes provide about 20% airflow when compared to solid plastic. Always test materials when it is 35°F or colder and before using these or any fabric or materials to protect plants.

Read the full article: 12 Ways to Protect Plants from Frost: Expert Tips

Continue reading