When should I apply starter fertilizer for new grass?

Published: June 09, 2025
Updated: June 09, 2025

Fertilizing is critical to new grass establishment. High-phosphorus blends (such as: 10-30-10) should be applied to the soil 7 days before seeding to prep the soil. In fact, I have witnessed my clients' germination rates increase by 70% simply following this step. Do not apply to an existing lawn, as overlapping can cause nitrogen surges that kills young roots.

Timing by Grass Type

  • Cool-season (Fescue/Ryegrass): Apply early September
  • Warm-season (Bermuda/Zoysia): Late May applications
  • Transition zones: Split April & October doses

Product Selection

  • NPK ratios: 12-24-12 ideal for most soils
  • Avoid urea-based starters in alkaline soils
  • Organic options: Bone meal (4-12-0) for pH <6.5
Starter Fertilizer Comparison
ProductScotts StarterNPK Ratio24-25-4Best ForCool-seasonRate3.5 lb/1k sq ftRegional Notes
Midwest banned after Nov 1
ProductPennington UltraNPK Ratio12-24-12Best ForWarm-seasonRate4 lb/1k sq ftRegional Notes
Florida requires 10ft buffer
ProductEspoma OrganicNPK Ratio4-12-0Best ForClay soilsRate6 lb/1k sq ftRegional Notes
California OMRI-certified
Color codes: red=legal restrictions, yellow=caution, green=safe

Soil characteristics in the region determine the adjustment. In the coastal Carolinas, fields may require 25% less phosphorus for acidic soils - we had a client with centipede grass that survived several years until we switched to 8-16-8. Midwest clay? Apply starter fertilizer, to the top 2" layer, at seeding to avoid a crusting effect from the soil surface layer.

Regional Application Windows
RegionNortheastCool-Season WindowAug 25-Sept 15Warm-Season WindowN/ABuffer Laws
25ft from wetlands
RegionSoutheastCool-Season WindowOct 1-Nov 1Warm-Season WindowMay 1-June 15Buffer Laws
10ft from ponds
RegionSouthwestCool-Season WindowN/AWarm-Season WindowApr 20-May 30Buffer Laws
Drip irrigation only
Based on 2024 USDA agricultural guidelines

Application Errors

  • Overlapping with established turf
  • Using high-nitrogen blends (causes burn)
  • Ignoring soil test phosphorus levels

Legal Oversights

  • Violating buffer zone laws
  • Applying during drought bans
  • Miscalculating phosphorus limits

Care following application is necessary to prevent washout. Water 0.1" per day for 7 days after application - heavy irrigation strips away phosphorus. A client's starter fertilizer (in Dallas) was lost when we received heavy unexpected rainfall; upon drying, we re-entered the area at 50% strength and successfully covered the area without any runoff.

Read the full article: When to Fertilize Lawn: By Region & Grass Type

Continue reading