What's better for weeds: pulling or spraying?
Written by
Benjamin Miller
Reviewed by
Prof. Charles Hartman, Ph.D.Selecting between hand pulling weeds and spraying treatment will depend on your garden situation. Hand pulling is effective with weeds growing individually or with roots that are easily accessible; spraying treatment is effective with weed infestations that are wider spread. Consider the type of weed, the size of the infested area, and if you have the time to take on the project when making your selection. Each method has its merits; for some situations, one is better than the other.
Manual Pulling
- Removes entire root systems preventing regrowth
- Requires physical effort but no chemicals
- Best after rain when soil is soft
- Ideal for edible gardens near vegetables
Spraying Solutions
- Covers large areas quickly with less labor
- Natural options like vinegar require repeat applications
- Use precise nozzles to avoid drift
- Effective on pavement and gravel surfaces
Combined Approach
- Spray first to weaken established weeds
- Pull dead roots 48 hours later
- Reduces chemical usage significantly
- Saves time on tough perennial weeds
Safety Considerations
- Wear gloves for pulling to protect hands
- Use goggles and masks when spraying
- Keep children/pets away during treatment
- Avoid windy days to prevent drift
Long-Term Strategy
- Mulch after removal to prevent regrowth
- Monitor weekly for new seedlings
- Improve soil health to favor desired plants
- Address underlying causes like compacted soil
Utilize both methods for best weed control, particularly for perennials. The vinegar solution will kill the foliage, and then the weakened roots can be easily pulled. I used this hybrid approach to save hours on maintaining my community garden plot. I suggest having a spray of vinegar solution saved for spring surges when weeds are coming on fast.
Focus on pulling weeds manually around vegetables and sensitive plants. I have a fish-tail weeder that I use near my tomato beds. In walkways, I only spray natural solutions on isolated weeds. Always mulch to prevent new weed growth after treating.
Read the full article: 10 Natural Weed Control Methods That Work
