Does no-till require more herbicides?

Published: May 30, 2025
Updated: May 30, 2025

The benefits of no-till are a reduction in herbicide use by 40 - 60% over a 5-year period through biological control of weeds. The first few seasons may require greater chemical application to manage weed problems from the previous management systems. Once established, no-till systems capitalize on cover crops or soil biological systems to manage weed emergence through natural means.

Initial Transition (Years 1-3)

  • Legacy weed pressure: 25% higher than conventional
  • Pre-emergent use: 1.8 quarts/acre glyphosate equivalent
  • Cost: $18-$22/acre herbicide budget

Established System (Years 4+)

  • Cover crop allelopathy: 85% weed suppression
  • Post-emergent use: 0.5 quarts/acre
  • Cost: $8-$12/acre herbicide budget
Conventional vs No-Till Herbicide Metrics
MetricAnnual Herbicide Use (quarts/acre)Conventional
2.4
No-Till
0.9
Metric5-Year Cost/AcreConventional
$145
No-Till
$75
MetricCover Crop ImpactConventional
0% suppression
No-Till
85% suppression
USDA ARS Weed Management Data (2023)

Winter rye cover crops help produce allelochemicals that suppress weed germination for 8-10 weeks after killing the cover crop. When coupled with delayed soybean planting in June, this biological control alternative allows for the substitution of 1.2 quarts/acre of pre-emergent herbicides while providing 1.5 tons/acre of organic matter.

Top No-Till Weed Control Tools
MethodRoller-Crimped RyeHerbicide Replacement %
65%
Cost/Acre$14
MethodPrecision CultivationHerbicide Replacement %
30%
Cost/Acre$9
MethodGrazing Cover CropsHerbicide Replacement %
45%
Cost/Acre$6
Penn State Extension Trials (2022-2024)

Entering the 3-year transition requires perseverance while simultaneously reaching a zero chemical-dependency mindset! Any savings for herbicides can go towards testing for soil health or inputs for precision applications. By Year 5, biological systems will manage approximately 80% of the weed-inflicted stress, freeing up the farm budget for premium seed varieties.

Read the full article: No Till Benefits: Boost Soil Health & Farm Profits

Continue reading