Can I grow tomatoes from grocery store fruits?

Published: May 19, 2025
Updated: May 19, 2025

You can grow your tomatoes from the fruits you buy in the store if you have a game plan. Hybrids usually produce uncertain offspring, and heirlooms seem to replicate the original plant. I have grown 12 varieties this way and some did well, while others did not do so well. You will want to use ultra-ripe, organic tomatoes to start from if you want a good chance of getting viable seeds.

Fermentation Process

  • Extract seeds: Scoop gel-covered seeds into a jar
  • Add water: Cover seeds, let sit 3 days until mold forms
  • Rinse/dry: Strain, rinse, dry on parchment for 1 week

Hybrid vs. Heirloom

  • Hybrids: 40% germination rate, unpredictable traits
  • Heirlooms: 85% germination, true-to-type fruits
  • Store-bought: Often hybrids; check for 'heirloom' labels
Seed Viability Comparison
VarietyGrocery HybridSeed ViabilityLow (30-50%)Germination Rate
Unpredictable
Best UseExperiments
VarietyHeirloomSeed ViabilityHigh (80-90%)Germination Rate
Reliable
Best UseSeed saving
Rates based on 3-year trials

Begin seeds 6-8 weeks ahead of the last frost date indoors. Utilize seed trays with heating mats for soil temperatures of around 75°F (24°C). I had the 'Beefsteak' tomato from a store that took 14 days to germinate, this was a slower germination time than seeds from my local nursery. Move hardened seedlings into 5-gallon containers that are filled with soil and have drainage holes in the bottom.

Low Germination

  • Cause: Old seeds, improper drying
  • Fix: Soak in chamomile tea 24 hours pre-planting
  • Prevent: Store seeds in airtight jars with silica packs

Disease Prevention

  • Sterilize: Dip seeds in 10% bleach solution pre-fermentation
  • Soil: Use sterile seed-starting mix
  • Spacing: Avoid crowding seedlings

Set expectations.My ‘Kumato' hybrid bore bland fruit, while a rescue ‘Brandywine' heirloom seed thrived. Keep records in a journal, noting flavor, yields, and overall plant health. Even failures provide valuable experience on the importance of genetics and seed viability.

Read the full article: How to Grow Tomatoes: Complete Beginner's Guide

Continue reading